Few bathroom decisions spark more debate at the kitchen table than this one: keep the tub, or tear it out for a walk-in shower? A large, open shower with glass and tile is one of the most requested updates in bathroom renovations today. It looks clean, it is easier to step into, and it can make a small room feel bigger. But a tub still matters to some households and some buyers. Here is how to think through the conversion and the other layout choices that come with it.
Should You Convert the Tub?
The practical question is not whether showers are popular, but whether a tub will be missed in your home. Consider:
- Who lives there now. Families with small children often rely on a tub for bath time. Adults who never bathe may get far more value from a roomy shower.
- Aging in place. Stepping over a tub wall becomes harder over time. A low-threshold or curbless shower with grab bar blocking in the walls is easier to use for years to come.
- How many bathrooms you have. Many real estate professionals suggest keeping at least one tub in the house for resale, especially in homes that appeal to families. If you have a hall bath with a tub, converting the primary bath is usually a safe choice. Converting the only tub in the house deserves more thought.
- How long you plan to stay. If this is your long-term home, design it for how you live.
What a Conversion Actually Involves
A standard alcove tub is typically about five feet long, which makes a comfortable shower footprint. The work usually includes removing the tub and surrounding walls down to the studs, adjusting the drain location and size for a shower, installing a new shower valve, building a properly sloped shower floor, and waterproofing everything before tile goes on.
Waterproofing is the part you never see and the part that matters most. Whether the system is a traditional mortar bed with a liner or a modern sheet or liquid-applied membrane, it must be continuous across the floor, curb and walls, and tied correctly into the drain. Shortcuts here lead to leaks that show up as stains on the ceiling below months later.
Curb or Curbless?
A curbless shower, where the bathroom floor flows into the shower with no step, looks sleek and is the most accessible option. It also requires recessing the shower floor so it can slope to the drain, which may mean modifying floor framing or, on a slab, cutting concrete. A linear drain along one wall can make the slope simpler. A low curb is less involved and still a big improvement over climbing into a tub.
Glass, Niches and Fixtures
- Glass enclosures: frameless glass shows off tile and keeps the room open, while semi-frameless options cost less. A fixed glass panel without a door works in some larger showers.
- Niches: recessed shelves built into the wall keep bottles off the floor. Plan them on interior walls when possible, since exterior walls hold insulation.
- Benches: built-in or fold-down seats are useful for shaving and for anyone who needs to sit.
- Valves and shower heads: a pressure-balancing or thermostatic valve, a handheld wand on a slide bar, and placing controls near the entry so you can turn on the water without getting soaked.
- Grab bar blocking: adding solid wood blocking in the walls during the remodel costs little and makes future grab bars easy to install securely.
Other Layout Decisions in the Same Project
Once the walls are open, it is a good time to rethink the whole room.
- Vanity: single or double sinks, wall-hung or floor-standing, and how much counter space you actually use. A double vanity typically needs a wide wall to avoid crowding.
- Toilet placement: moving a toilet means moving its drain, which is simpler over an accessible basement or crawl space and harder on a slab or over a finished ceiling. Codes set minimum clearances around toilets, so check spacing before finalizing the plan.
- Ventilation: a properly sized exhaust fan vented outdoors, not into the attic, protects your new tile and paint from moisture.
- Lighting: layered lighting with good vanity lighting at face level, not only overhead.
- Storage: linen cabinets, medicine cabinets recessed between studs and drawers in the vanity.
- Flooring: porcelain tile is the standard choice in bathrooms, and heated floors are a popular upgrade. Our guide to hardwood, luxury vinyl and tile explains why.
Permits and Budget
Replacing a tub with a shower often involves plumbing changes, and relocating fixtures, adding circuits or altering walls typically requires a permit from your local construction office. Seven Wonders handles permitting on our projects; see our NJ permit guide for the general rules.
The bathroom renovations we price typically range from about $6K to $45K and up. A straightforward tub-to-shower swap in the same footprint sits toward the lower part of that range, while a full remodel with a curbless shower, moved fixtures, custom glass and heated floors sits higher. For a deeper look at what drives the number, read our bathroom renovation cost guide for New Jersey homeowners.
Design the Bathroom You Will Actually Use
Seven Wonders Construction renovates bathrooms across New Jersey, from simple conversions to complete remodels. Explore our bathroom renovation service, and if the basement needs a new bathroom too, see our basement finishing service. Request a free quote or call (908) 397-4084 to talk through your layout.

