Three materials cover most of the floors we are asked to install in New Jersey homes: hardwood, luxury vinyl plank (often called LVP) and tile. Each one is a good choice somewhere in the house and a poor choice somewhere else. The right answer depends less on which floor is "best" and more on the room, the subfloor, the people and pets living there, and how long you plan to stay. Here is a practical way to think through the decision.
How New Jersey Conditions Affect Flooring
New Jersey has humid summers and dry, heated winters. Wood is a natural material that absorbs and releases moisture, so it expands in August and shrinks in January. That seasonal movement is normal, and a properly acclimated and installed wood floor handles it with small, temporary gaps. It becomes a problem when wood goes into a space with ongoing moisture, like a basement slab or a bathroom. Many homes here also have older subfloors, slabs on grade, or radiant heat, and each of those affects which products and installation methods will work.
Hardwood: Timeless, Repairable, Moisture-Sensitive
Solid hardwood is what many buyers expect to see in living rooms, dining rooms, hallways and bedrooms, especially in older colonials and Cape Cods. Its big advantage is longevity. A solid floor can usually be sanded and refinished several times over its life, so scratches and worn finish are fixable rather than permanent.
- Best for: main living areas, bedrooms, stairs and hallways on wood subfloors above grade.
- Watch out for: standing water, pet accidents left to sit, and below-grade installs. Solid hardwood is generally not recommended directly over basement concrete.
- Engineered hardwood uses a real wood top layer over a more stable core. It moves less with humidity and can be used in some places solid wood cannot, though how many times it can be refinished depends on the thickness of the wear layer.
Luxury Vinyl Plank: Practical and Water-Resistant
LVP has improved a great deal. Better products now have convincing wood visuals, textured surfaces and rigid cores that click together as a floating floor. Most are highly water-resistant, which makes them a strong choice for basements, kitchens, laundry rooms and homes with pets or young kids.
- Best for: basements, kitchens, mudrooms, rentals and busy family spaces.
- Watch out for: wide variation in quality. Wear layer thickness, core type and the locking system matter. A very cheap product can look and feel cheap.
- Limitations: LVP cannot be refinished. Deep gouges mean replacing planks, so it is smart to keep a box of extras. It also needs a flat subfloor; dips and humps show through or stress the joints.
"Water-resistant" usually means the planks themselves tolerate spills. It does not mean a floating floor can survive a flood without being pulled up. Water that gets underneath still has to be dried out.
Tile: The Most Durable Option for Wet Rooms
Porcelain and ceramic tile are hard to beat in bathrooms, entryways, laundry rooms and kitchens. Porcelain is dense and absorbs very little water, holds up to heavy traffic and is easy to clean. Large-format and wood-look porcelain planks have made tile popular beyond the bathroom.
- Best for: bathrooms, showers, entries, laundry rooms and kitchens.
- Watch out for: tile is cold and hard underfoot, and dropped glasses do not survive. Radiant floor heat is a popular add-on in bathrooms for that reason.
- Installation matters: tile needs a stiff, flat substrate. Over a wood subfloor that flexes, tile and grout crack. Proper underlayment and, in wet areas, waterproofing are essential.
Natural stone such as marble or slate falls in the same family but usually needs sealing and more care than porcelain.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Factor | Hardwood | Luxury Vinyl Plank | Porcelain Tile |
|---|---|---|---|
| Water tolerance | Low | High (surface) | Very high |
| Basement use | Engineered only, with care | Excellent | Excellent |
| Comfort underfoot | Warm, some give | Warm, some give | Hard and cool |
| Repair options | Sand and refinish | Replace planks | Replace tiles |
| Installation time | Moderate | Usually fastest | Usually slowest |
A Room-by-Room Starting Point
- Living and dining rooms: hardwood or engineered wood, unless pets and kids push you toward LVP.
- Kitchen: any of the three can work. Tile is the most water-proof, LVP is the most forgiving, and hardwood creates continuity with adjoining rooms. If a kitchen remodel is on your list, our kitchen remodeling team can coordinate flooring with cabinets so the floor runs where it should.
- Bathrooms: tile, almost always. Our bathroom renovation service includes proper waterproofing beneath the tile.
- Basement: LVP or tile. For more on what goes into a below-grade space, read our guide to finishing a basement in New Jersey.
- Bedrooms: hardwood, engineered wood, or LVP; some homeowners still prefer carpet here.
Do Not Forget What Is Underneath
The finished floor is only as good as the subfloor and prep beneath it. Before installation, a contractor should check for squeaks, loose or damaged subfloor, levelness, and moisture in concrete. Removing old flooring, especially older sheet vinyl or tile that may contain asbestos in homes built decades ago, may need testing before it is disturbed. Thresholds, transitions between rooms and trim details also affect how finished the job looks.
You may also find it helpful to browse our residential design trends post for how homeowners are pairing floors with cabinets and paint.
Get a Floor That Fits Your Home
Seven Wonders Construction installs hardwood, engineered wood, luxury vinyl and tile throughout New Jersey. See our flooring installation service for more detail, then request a free quote or call (908) 397-4084. We will look at your subfloor, talk through how you use each room and recommend a material that will hold up.

